Man wins Rs 5 lakh refund with 9% interest over developer's failure to register plots
NEW DELHI: A district consumer commission in Telangana has directed a developer and its chairman to refund Rs 5 lakh to a man after the company failed to register two residential plots despite collecting advance payments. The commission held that the developer was guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.What was the dispute about?The complainant, Sanisetty Jagadeesh Babu, a 47-year-old private employee from Hyderabad, entered into two agreements of sale with Pudami Developers for residential plots measuring 200 square yards each in its Sunray City Township Phase-I project at Kadthal, Ranga Reddy district.The first agreement, dated April 8, 2021, was for plot No.253 at Rs 8.4 lakh, while the second, dated August 7, 2021, was for plot No.53 at Rs 8.6 lakh.
He paid a total advance of Rs 5 lakh for the two plots, with the remaining amount payable at the time of registration.He alleged that despite expressing his willingness to pay the balance amount, the developers neither accepted it nor initiated steps to register the plots in his name.He further alleged that the company's managing director had shifted business addresses and invested money collected from purchasers in another property at Kolanupaka in Yadadri Bhuvanagiri district.When he traced the developers and demanded registration, they allegedly executed a promissory note on January 29, 2023, promising to repay Rs 5.92 lakh if the plots were not registered.After his legal notice dated October 12, 2023, was returned, he approached the commission seeking registration of the plots or alternative plots, Rs 2 lakh compensation and Rs 50,000 towards litigation costs.The developers did not appear or file their written response despite notices, including newspaper publication.
They were proceeded against ex-parte.What did the commission say?The bench comprising president Chitneni Latha Kumari and members D Madhavi Latha and Kathyayani Khandavilli found that the sale agreements and payment receipts established that the developers had collected Rs 5 lakh and agreed to execute registered sale deeds.It also noted that the promissory note for Rs 5.92 lakh supported the complainant's case."The above documentary evidence makes it amply clear that the Opposite Party No.1-Sri Nidamanuri Mohan Rao, Chairman and Managing Director committed deficiency in service and adopted an unfair trade practice," the commission noted.It held that the managing director was liable to refund the amount with interest instead of directing registration of the plots.
However, it dismissed the claims against opposite parties 2 to 4.Final orderIn its November 12, 2026 order, the commission partly allowed the complaint and directed opposite party No.1, Nidamanuri Mohan Rao Gupta, to pay:Rs 5 lakh with 9 percent annual interest from August 7, 2021, till realisation.Rs 10,000 towards litigation costs.The remaining claims were disallowed. The order must be complied with within 45 days of receipt, failing which the interest rate will increase to 12 percent per annum from the date of default till realisation.