Hyderabad woman gets empty Myntra jewellery parcel, wins Rs 20,830 payout
NEW DELHI: A district consumer commission in Ranga Reddy has directed Myntra India and jewellery seller Kushal's Retail to jointly refund Rs 15,830 to a woman who received an empty parcel instead of the studded and beaded jewellery set she had ordered online. The commission held both companies liable for deficiency in service.What was the dispute about?The complainant, Sai Sree V, a 31-year-old private employee from Hyderabad, ordered a studded and beaded jewellery set through Myntra's online platform on April 15, 2024, for Rs 15,830.
The product was sold by Kushal's Retail Pvt Ltd and the entire amount was paid in advance.The parcel was delivered on April 20, 2024. However, upon opening it, she found that the package was empty and did not contain the ordered jewellery.She immediately raised a complaint through Myntra's Help Centre. However, despite repeated requests, neither the jewellery was delivered nor was the amount refunded.Myntra rejected her refund request, stating that the product had undergone a mandatory quality check and was dispatched in tamper-proof packaging.Myntra, in its response, argued that it operated only as an online marketplace connecting independent sellers with customers.
It said the seller was responsible for delivery and claimed protection under Section 79 of the Information Technology Act.Kushal's Retail was served notice but did not appear before the commission or file a written response within the prescribed 45-day period.What did the commission say?The bench comprising Chitneni Latha Kumari (President) and D. Madhavi Latha (Member) found that the complainant had promptly reported the missing jewellery but neither company produced sufficient evidence to establish that the product had actually been packed and delivered.The commission noted that Myntra failed to produce quality-check reports, packing records, dispatch weight particulars or delivery verification records to support its claim that the jewellery was dispatched in sealed packaging.It also rejected Myntra's argument that it was merely an intermediary, observing that the company had collected platform fees and handled the complainant's grievance.The commission said that under Rule 4(5) of the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020, e-commerce entities must acknowledge complaints within 48 hours and resolve them within one month."The conduct of the Opposite Parties amounts to deficiency in service within the meaning of Section 2(11) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019," the commission noted.However, it said the evidence was insufficient to establish a separate case of unfair trade practice.Final orderAnnounced on November 6, 2026, the order partly allowed the complaint.
The commission directed Myntra India and Kushal's Retail to jointly and severally pay:Rs 15,830 as refund, along with 9 percent annual interest from April 15, 2024, till realisation.Rs 3,000 as compensation for mental agony and inconvenience.Rs 2,000 towards litigation costs.The companies must comply with the order within 45 days of receiving it.