'India not a rogue state': Wangchuk says 'house arrest' lifted after court hearing
NEW DELHI: Climate activist Sonam Wangchuk on Saturday hailed the court's intervention in the restrictions imposed on his movement in Leh. He said that the administration withdrew police personnel deployed outside his residence only after the matter came up for hearing.Joining the Leh Apex Body (LAB)-led protest, Wangchuk said he had been under effective house arrest since November 11 and appealed to President Droupadi Murmu and Prime Minister Narendra Modi to uphold constitutional values and democratic freedoms."India is not a rogue state.
It is the world's largest democracy, and it has certain constitutional values and standards that must be upheld," Wangchuk said at a press conference with LAB chairman Chering Dorje Lakruk.His remarks came a day after Leh district police withdrew the arrangements made outside his residence to ensure compliance with a prohibitory order. The police, however, denied that Wangchuk had been placed under house arrest.In a post on X, Leh district police said, "Police arrangements which (were) placed to ensure compliance with prohibitory order have been withdrawn.
ADM (Additional District magistrate), Leh has passed a prohibitory order against Wangchuk. It is clarified that he was not put under any house arrest as has been claimed."Wangchuk questioned the police's explanation, alleging that the administration was denying restrictions on his movement despite having deployed personnel outside his residence."This is an extremely strange way for a government to function.
The State is behaving like a rogue state, where anyone can simply be picked up and detained. But when it is required to face the truth in a court of law, it suddenly claims that nothing happened and that there was no such detention," he said, referring to his earlier arrest under the National Security Act (NSA).Wangchuk recounts events leading to court proceedingsRecounting the events of November 11, Wangchuk alleged that he was forcibly picked up while preparations were underway for an indefinite protest.
The demonstration was planned to press for the resumption of dialogue with the Centre and seek a deferment of the Hill Council elections scheduled for December 4."Those who came were wearing masks and hoodies, with their faces concealed. I would hesitate to even call them policemen because they looked more like goons," he said.Wangchuk claimed that although he had agreed to go to jail, he was instead taken to his residence at the Himalayan Institute of Alternatives, Ladakh (HIAL).
He alleged that nearly two dozen local police and CRPF personnel, dressed in commando fatigues and carrying firearms, were deployed there.The activist said he subsequently decided to challenge the restrictions through legal channels, with the help of lawyers in Delhi and Ladakh.According to Wangchuk, an appeal was filed before the High Court bench in Leh on November 17 and listed for hearing the following day.
He claimed that no government representative appeared during the November 18 hearing. The court then gave the government time until November 19 to submit its response.He said Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta appeared before the court on November 19 and sought time until November 23, which was granted."Taking advantage of this time, the authorities withdrew all the personnel deployed outside my residence Friday night," Wangchuk said.Wangchuk appeals to President, PMWangchuk also expressed concern over the alleged use of police personnel and government officials to carry out actions that could compromise their professional responsibilities."I hope that when they joined the civil services, whether the IPS or IAS, they did so with great aspirations and a genuine desire to serve the country.
Today, however, they are being used and misused like pawns in what resembles a mafia gang," he said.Appealing to people across the country, he urged the government to ensure that officials and police personnel were allowed to perform their duties within the bounds of the law."I have appealed to President Murmu and the prime minister to put an end to this lawlessness and ensure that our officers and police personnel are allowed to discharge their duties with dignity and within the bounds of the law," he said.Wangchuk also defended the ongoing sit-in, saying he had joined his colleagues at the protest site.
He said the demonstration had continued for 10 days and was peaceful and authorised.Wangchuk renews opposition to winter Hill Council pollsThe activist also reiterated his opposition to holding the Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council (LAHDC) elections during winter. He argued that a significant section of the population would be outside Ladakh during the season and would not be able to participate."On the one hand, we send a message to the world that we take democracy to the last citizen, even flying helicopters to polling stations where there are just two voters.
On the other hand, we are excluding 40 to 50 per cent of the population and conducting elections during winter, amid snowfall, while also subjecting government officials to immense hardship," he said.Wangchuk clarified that people were not opposed to elections but wanted them held during a season that would allow wider public participation. He also pointed to the difficulties of deploying government officials in remote and snowbound areas during winter.He urged the government to reconsider the schedule and ensure that democratic processes in Ladakh remained inclusive rather than being imposed on the people.Get the latest India News and Live updates.
Download the TOI app.