Is forfieting copies of a book the right way to handle ‘objectionable content’?
Bengaluru The Karnataka Cabinet’s decision to forfeit copies of the book Basava Mantapa, by NRI author Ravi Hanj, over alleged “derogatory” remarks against 12th-century social reformer Basavanna, has reignited the debate over whether banning or forfeiting a book is the right approach. While several writers, even as they oppose the contents of the book, take the stand that no book should be banned, a few, including police officers, argue that the line between freedom of expression and hate speech is a blur, particularly when public order is threatened.
Not the first case However, this is not the first time a book has been banned/forfeited in Karnataka. Including Basava Mantapa, at least six books have been banned or forfeited in the State to date post-Independence, mostly over hurt religious sentiments. The courts have also upheld such decisions, such as in the case of Dharmakarana by P.V. Narayana in 1997. In the case of Dhundhi (2013), it was the court’s ruling that led to an effective ban.
There have been demands to ban several other books, which eventually did not result in any restrictions. Authors oppose ban Banjagere Jayaprakash — whose book Aanudeva Horaganavanu, an academic work that propounded an alternate origin story of Basavanna and was banned in 2007 — said, “The answer to any book should be another book.” However, he added that not all books that face opposition can be put in the same basket.
The intent, language and academic rigour matter too, he added. Yogesh Master, whose novel Dhundhi was banned, said that banning a book deprives the academic world of an opportunity to read it and debate it. “A book will lose credibility if it is exposed to be hollow, not by banning it,” he said. He added that the statements of Mr. Hanj amounted to a “cultural insult to Kannada”, as Basavanna was not only a Lingayat religious leader, but a socio-cultural icon of the State.
Threat to public order? Arvind Narrain, president of the People’s Union of Civil Liberties, Karnataka, said the Constitution provides for a ban or forfeiture of a book on three grounds: national security, threat to public order and threat to public morality. In this case, though the notification for the forfeiture is not yet out, it is clear that the government has invoked a threat to public order, relevant sections of which have been invoked in the four FIRs registered against the author.
“There have been some protests across the State over the book, but is that a threat to public order that the government cannot handle?” he asked, adding that the ban of a book was “the language of an oppressive State” and should not be that of a government that claims to uphold Constitutional values. “Freedom of expression should be protected to the maximum extent, and limitation should be minimal,” he said.
All six books in the State have been banned or forfeited following protests by caste or religious groups over hurt sentiments. Where to draw the line? Senior writer K. Marulasiddappa said that while, in principle, banning a book was unacceptable, the question of disturbance to public order was a valid ground. He also said the line gets blurred when the writing in question borders on hate speech.
Mr. Narrain suggested that the State book FIRs under provisions of hate speech against such persons. The Bengaluru City Police recently stopped the staging of a controversial play, Gandhi Hatyeya Satya by Addanda C. Cariappa, following protests and the playwright being smeared with ink. The complaint against the play said it portrayed Mahatma Gandhi in a derogatory manner and made the audience raise slogans against him.
Following this, the city police have reportedly been asking for the submission of the scripts of some plays under the colonial-era law, the Dramatic Performances Act, 1876, still on the books but rarely invoked. Poet and playwright Raghunandana said that while the play can be criticised, smearing ink on the playwright and forcing the police to suspend its staging was not right.
“This gives the State space for censorship. We have invited this upon ourselves, as with a book,” he said.